← Back to all One Page Business Stories
|
Free resources & newsletter

The rise and fall of Subway: The $11 billion empire that crumbled

The sandwich chain that hit 44,000 locations by opening a new store every 8 hours — then trained customers to expect $5 sandwiches and couldn't escape.
Watch this on YouTube

By The Numbers

44,000
locations at peak
$5
footlong promo price
$9B
fire-sale to private equity

What They Nailed Early

Created the first accessible franchise model for sandwiches — just $150K to open vs. $1M for McDonald's. Rode the low-fat health trend perfectly. Hit massive scale with 40,000+ locations by making fresh subs the affordable alternative to greasy burgers.

What Changed

Growth-at-all-costs culture cannibalized its own stores. The $5 footlong trained customers to expect dirt-cheap calories, boxing the brand into value hell. Founder Fred DeLuca got sick in 2013, exposing zero succession planning. Competitors attacked from both sides — Chipotle and Jersey Mike's took quality seekers, Taco Bell took value hunters.

Where it Landed

Same-store sales declining since 2012. Closed thousands of stores. Families sold to private equity for $9B in 2023 after failing to get $10B. New owners cleaning house, but 37,000 locations still standing on shaky ground.

The Principles

1. 
Growth at all costs kills. Subway cannibalized its own franchises, charged predatory fees, and opened stores that competed with each other instead of rivals.
2. 
Promotions train customers forever. The $5 footlong generated $3.8B in one year but permanently anchored the brand to value pricing they couldn't escape.
3. 
Founder dependency is an existential risk. When Fred got sick, the company had no real leadership structure and ground to a halt during its biggest crisis.

Builder's Takeaway

3 warning signs your growth strategy is cannibalizing your business:
• 
You're opening new locations that steal from existing ones, not competitors
• 
Your promotions train customers to wait for discounts instead of valuing quality
• 
Franchisees are 15x more likely to sue you than industry average
Want the whole story? → Watch this on YouTube